Aqua Resist Color Pencil 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner

This is the second time I have received an eye pencil from Makeup Forever that has been like this when I opened it up. The liner is so crumbly, and it doesn’t sharpen and it’s a disaster. These are freaking expensive. Get your crap together! I am never buying this sh again.

Absolutely love the color and formula! It goes on so smooth, is very long lasting and suits my brown eyes so well. I love to apply it to my water line. Definitely a great staple in my makeup collection!

I love a creamy eyeliner pencil and I wouldn't normally go with a black pencil but this blended out so smoothly and looks beautiful with a dark shadow or a shimmer with it. I have been using it for my work makeup looks all week. Definitely a must buy.

I love how versatile this eyeliner is. It applies very smoothly and is easy to blend. It lasts long on my waterline and I don’t have to reapply it. The brown shade is more warm than cool toned and looks great for brown colored eyes.

I bought "cool ebony" and it lives up to the hype. Smudges easily, stays put once it sets and delivers a rich color. Can be used for a wing liner and in the waterline and goes on smoothly. I also bought "Unlimited lvy" which is metallic and "desert taupe" which is a shimmer. These colors are beautiful but unfortunately the metallics and shimmers do not seem to work in the waterline. So i figured I will just use them for regular eyeliner on my lashline. They are not as creamy and do not glide as easily as the matte shade does. I will still use them but it takes a little more to get them to work and the colors are not as impactful as when you swatch it on your hand.

I love how creamy and smooth this pencil feels; the color is vibrant, and I liked the formula because it lasted all day. I think the size is perfect, and I’m going to order more colors. If you’re looking for an easy to use eye pencil, I really like this one.

Horrible update! I still have the previous version of this eyeliner and it was so much better. The new one is shorter (less product), does not twist up (impossible to use), and the packaging feels hollow (cheap). I went to the store today because I wanted one that works and was informed I would have to sharpen it on my own and I would have to purchase a separate sharpener. Why does the end of the pencil twist if it is not going to lengthen and sharpen the product? No one wants anything this difficult to use. I am rushing to get ready in the mornings or touch up later in the day and every second counts. I do not have time for this and will not buy again.

Pencil is difficult to turn and does not raise the pencil so cannot be used for more than a week . Can’t get hold of customer service. Just wasted 3x$27.00 on 3 pencils its new version. MItaly

After using this for a few weeks went to turn the pencil n raise the pencil but it does not raise . Totally different from original. DO NOT BUY . Happy

Sadly, I have to agree with all the other reviewers who have been faithful fans of MUFE Aqua Resist for years but now are looking for another brand. The old formula was the best on the market in terms of smudge proof all day (and night) wear. The new formula still works well on, with rich colors - however the pencil is impossible. I can’t get it sharp enough to work well, and it keeps scratching my eyelid. I literally have to sharpen it for each eye, and still it’s painful. It’s almost gone and I’ve only used it a few weeks. I really wish they hadn’t tried to fix something that wasn’t broken.