Cole Haan Women's Valantina Pointed Toe Block Heel Loafers

I bought the tan suede version, and the combination of a pointed toe with flexible suede means the toes aren’t pinched and with a low heel that design combination is perfect. However, one of the shoes I received is 1/4 to 1/2 size larger than the other, the top edges of the shoe where it reaches the ankle are sharp and cut into the skin after wearing a while. Also, there is little to no padding on sole.

One shoe was about 1/2 size larger than the other despite my feet being the same size. Poor quality, stiff leather. I purchased heel pads for the "too large" shoe and they haven't arrived yet but hope they work. Gave 3 stars because a pointed toe design with a low heel is hard to find, but they can be comfortable and look good with loose jeans.

I received used shoes. The soles were marked up and there were scuff marks on the side. Completely disappointing. Other than that, the fit is very narrow—size up half a size.

Comfortable but narrow

Very stylish with pants and bootcut jeans. Just what I was looking for, the look of a heal in a flat. Leather gets softer each time I wear them.

Decent looking shoe, material needs a lot of care to maintain, and the shoe bites.

uncomfortable and oddly sized.

I have these in black. They are super cute and the style gives the illusion that you have on heels if you are wearing trousers. I have only worn them a few times this year and the stitching is starting to come loose around the front of the shoes.

Great look and quality! They do run very large. I should have gone down a size, however, I used a thick insert and they fit fine. The loafers look awesome with jeans!

I love the style of this loafer, very classy. I have narrow feet and for the most part the shoes are comfortable however the toe area is a bit snug (not because the shoe size to small). I do think overtime that area of the shoe will stretch to be comfortable. I normally wear an 8.5. I bought a size 8.5 in this particular shoe. I’m keeping them. 👍🏻