Estée Lauder Smoke and Brighten Long-Lasting Waterproof Kajal Eyeliner Duo

I like the concept of this dual-colored liner and that the lighter color is off white and not bright white. However, the black eyeliner portion of the stick feel out when I opened it. It may have been related to the way in which it was shipped (in just a regular, non-damage proof mailer), but that was disappointing.

I love Estée Lauder products but this is one of the worst things I ever bought. The pencil was broken at the tip when I got it and every time I sharpen it, it kept breaking. I couldn’t even keep a decent tip on it because it would break. It was the same on both ends. I was extremely disappointed.

Very smooth and easy to apply

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this duo. I am happy to learn about Kajal liners. They glide on easily and stay put. The lining is a generous size, unlike other pencil liners. I have not used a brightener before and find it really makes my eyes pop. A great duo.

I got this one last month and was so excited to use ! After couple use both sides got broken the actual kohl came out of the whole pencil from both sides !

Excellent purchase

The intense color stays put. It glides on your lids and doesn’t smudge.

I love it

Just bought a second one at full price ( and now it's on sale of course !) I just use the dark brown during the day then brighten up at night by touching up with both… perfect shades and just the right amount of shimmer ! !

Can't beat Estee Lauder - pencil is very nice and goes on smoothly