Johnston & Murphy Men's McGuffey Slip On Shoes

Quality of leather and sole doesn’t reach previous generation of the shoe. I’m very disappointed.

These shoes slip on easily and still fit snugly. The materials are up to J&M standards of quality and they remain comfortable on your feet all day.

Comfortable/stylish shoe. I didn't realize how badly the insides of my previous shoes were until I put these on. Highly recommend.

I returned these shoes because they didn’t quite look like how I expected. The oiled leather made this particular shoe look dirty. I instead got another pair of J&M shoes that I like better.

I bought these last minute fully knowing that fit would not be an issue based on past purchases. The color took a little getting used to but that is the way they designed. They fit just fine. I would recommend as they are a good value.

Very comfortable right out of the box. The light tan oil finish looks incredible. I am using the J&M oil tanned leather restorer to polish them. It took me a while to find the care for the shoes, please add recommended polish and care to the description of all shoes to remove the guess work. The shoes feel like they sit lower due to a thinner sole, but they actually are supported very well and feel very comfortable on my 58 year old knees and feet.

Love the shoe, except my high arches are forming a crease on the upper which takes away from the sleek design. One star off for that.

I've never owned a loafer that fit so well and felt so comfortable!

This is the third pair of these I have purchased and will continue to buy them as well. They are comfortable, true to size and are a great casual shoe to wear with Jeans or Shorts

A shoe you can ware all day in comfort. Very nice looking shoe.